There’s a popular belief floating around in the online author space: “The algorithm is broken. It’s shadow-banning me. That’s why no one sees my posts.”
It’s an easy conclusion to reach when you’re pouring time and effort into creating content, only to be met with silence. But let’s cut through the noise and look at what’s actually happening.
The algorithm isn’t broken. It’s not sabotaging you. And no, it’s not targeting you personally.
Algorithms don’t have emotions. They don’t play favorites. They aren’t capable of waking up one morning and deciding, “Let’s tank this author’s visibility just for fun.” They’re simply sets of rules designed to reward content that performs, and ignore content that doesn’t.
That means if your posts aren’t gaining traction, it’s not because the algorithm is out to get you. It’s because your content isn’t giving it a reason to distribute further. In plain terms, the algorithm boosts what people engage with. If your audience isn’t interacting with your content—liking, commenting, saving, sharing—it’s unlikely to be shown to more people.
That might sound discouraging at first. But here’s the empowering part: If the problem isn’t the algorithm, then you have control.
Once you understand how engagement actually works—and what kind of content captures attention, builds trust, and sparks interaction—you’re no longer at the mercy of a mysterious system. You can stop spinning your wheels with low-return tactics and start building strategic content that drives both visibility and sales.
Why Most Author Content Fails
Let’s get real for a moment. Writing a great book is one thing. Marketing that book effectively? That’s a different skill set altogether. And it starts with understanding where most indie authors go wrong when trying to show up online.
Here are four common missteps that may be sabotaging your content—and what to do instead.
1. Only Talking About Your Book
Endless posts about your book’s release date, your word count, or your characters might seem natural (after all, you’re proud of your work), but if that’s all your content offers, readers will quickly disengage. Promotion without connection rarely converts.
Why this fails: People don’t buy books—they buy stories, experiences, and relationships. And those connections start with you, not just your product.
What to do instead: Share the why behind your book. Offer behind-the-scenes glimpses of your writing process. Talk about the personal themes in your story or the emotional journey that led you to write it. Let people get to know the human behind the pen.
2. Posting Just to Stay Visible
There’s a myth that more content equals better results. So, many authors find themselves churning out daily posts without any real strategy or message. But without intention, frequency just leads to fatigue—both for you and for your audience.
Why this fails: Volume without clarity dilutes your message. Eventually, your posts become background noise.
What to do instead: Post less often, but with more intention. Create content with a clear purpose—whether it’s to build curiosity, drive traffic to your website, or spark conversation. Quality beats quantity, every time.
3. Lack of Engagement Prompts
You’ve written a post. You’ve shared a beautiful graphic. You’ve said something meaningful. And then… crickets. Why? Because you didn’t invite your audience to do anything with the information you gave them.
Why this fails: Social media is interactive by nature. Without a call to action or prompt for engagement, most people will simply scroll on.
What to do instead: End each post with a simple, compelling question or prompt. Ask for their opinion. Invite them to comment, share, or tag a friend. Even better—create content that encourages them to save it for later or share it to their Stories. These micro-interactions add up.
4. Generic, Forgettable Content
If your posts could be copied, pasted, and published by any other author and still make sense, they’re not doing enough to stand out. Blending in doesn’t get you remembered—it gets you overlooked.
Why this fails: Readers are bombarded with content daily. If your posts don’t spark emotion, curiosity, or connection, they won’t stop scrolling.
What to do instead: Lean into your uniqueness. Use your voice. Share real experiences, honest thoughts, and visuals that reflect your brand. Even if it feels a little vulnerable at first, the reward is deeper reader connection and long-term loyalty.
What the Algorithm Actually Rewards
Let’s be crystal clear about one thing: The algorithm’s job is to reward engagement. If your goal is to get your content in front of more eyes, you need to understand that the algorithm operates based on interaction, not just visibility.
The algorithm doesn’t care about how pretty your post looks, how many hashtags you use, or even how often you post. What it cares about is how much people interact with your content. More specifically, it rewards posts that get:
- Saves: When someone saves your post, it signals that they found value in it and may want to come back to it later. This is one of the strongest forms of engagement.
- Shares: Sharing is a direct indication that your content resonated so deeply that the reader wants to pass it along to their network. Shares expand your reach exponentially.
- Comments: Comments show deeper engagement. When people take the time to respond to your post, it creates a conversation, and the algorithm loves content that sparks dialogue.
- Clicks: Every click—whether it’s on a link in your post or your profile—signals that people are interested enough to dive deeper into what you have to offer. This is a key driver of visibility.
The basic chain reaction is simple:
- More engagement → more reach
When people engage with your content, the algorithm takes it as a sign that the post is valuable and worthy of being seen by more people. - More reach → more visibility
The more people your post reaches, the more likely it is that new, potential readers will find it and engage. Increased visibility is exactly what you need to get your book in front of the right audience. - More visibility → more book sales
This is the end goal, right? When more people see your posts and engage with them, you have a higher chance of converting that attention into actual book sales.
It’s not magic. It’s a clear cause-and-effect cycle: More interaction equals more visibility, and more visibility leads to more sales.
And the best part? This is a process you can control. The more you understand how the algorithm works, the more you can leverage it to your advantage.
The good news: It’s entirely learnable. By focusing on creating content that drives engagement, not just passive likes or shares, but deep, meaningful interaction, you can build an ecosystem where your content is continually pushed to new audiences. This isn’t about “beating the algorithm”; it’s about working with it and using its rules to grow your presence.
Content That Converts: What to Focus On
Here’s what high-performing, conversion-focused content usually includes:
1. A Strong Hook
You have 1–2 seconds to stop someone mid-scroll. Start with something surprising, emotional, or relatable. Weak openings are the death of good content.
Examples:
- “I almost quit writing last year. Here’s why I didn’t.”
- “My latest book flopped. Here’s what I learned.”
- “What every author needs to know about book marketing—and no one’s saying.”
2. Value-Driven Messaging
Your audience is asking, “What’s in it for me?” Make sure each post answers that. Value can come in the form of education, entertainment, or emotional resonance—but it has to be about them, not just about you.
3. Authentic Storytelling
People connect with people. Show your face. Share your process. Talk about the messy middle. Give readers a reason to root for you, not just your book.
4. Clear Calls to Action (CTAs)
Don’t assume readers will know what to do next. Whether you want them to comment, save, share, or click a link—tell them. A strong CTA turns passive scrollers into active supporters.
Questions Every Indie Author Should Ask Before Posting
Before you hit publish, pause and ask:
- Am I creating content that people want to engage with?
- Am I hooking attention in the first 2 seconds?
- Am I offering value—or just shouting, “Buy my book!” into the void?
If the answer to any of those questions is “no,” it’s time to rework the post.
The Algorithm Isn’t Your Enemy
Let’s get something straight: The authors who consistently sell books? They aren’t just “lucky.” They’ve figured out how to leverage the power of the algorithm to their advantage.
These authors don’t rely on guesswork or hope—they’ve mastered a strategic approach to marketing that creates sustainable results. They understand that the algorithm is a tool, not an obstacle, and they’ve learned how to work with it, not against it. Here’s how they do it:
1. Marketing with Strategy, Not Guesswork
Successful authors approach marketing with intention and a plan. They don’t post randomly and hope for the best. Instead, they create content with a clear purpose: to engage their audience, build visibility, and drive sales. This kind of thoughtful marketing doesn’t happen by chance. It’s built on understanding what works and continuously refining their approach based on what the data shows.
A strategic marketing plan is rooted in audience research, understanding what types of content resonate with your followers, and knowing how to use analytics to measure success. Once you’ve got a strategy in place, you can optimize your content for better results.
2. Creating Content That Earns Attention
Let’s face it: not all content is created equal. In a crowded online space, it’s not enough to just show up. You need to create content that grabs people’s attention and keeps them engaged. Content that hooks readers right away, sparks curiosity, and encourages interaction is the content that gets noticed—and that’s exactly what the algorithm rewards.
The authors who succeed aren’t just posting pretty pictures of their books—they’re crafting posts that offer value, tell stories, entertain, educate, and invite conversation. This type of content doesn’t just attract engagement; it encourages followers to become active participants in your journey as an author.
3. Working with the Algorithm, Not Against It
The algorithm isn’t your enemy. In fact, it’s a powerful ally if you know how to work with it. Rather than fighting against the algorithm or blaming it when your content doesn’t perform, focus on creating posts that the algorithm loves: content that gets interactions (likes, comments, shares, saves), posts that get clicked, and messages that spark conversations.
Once you understand the algorithm’s mechanics, you can start tailoring your content to fit within its parameters, ensuring that your posts get seen by more people, potential readers who will be interested in your work.
The Key Takeaway:
Once you stop seeing the algorithm as a challenge to overcome and start seeing it as a tool to amplify your reach, you’ll realize that success doesn’t have to be a matter of luck. It’s about creating a system that works—one that supports your goals while you focus on writing and creating.
You don’t need to rely on hustle or hope anymore. With the right strategy and a clear understanding of how the algorithm works, you can develop a marketing plan that works for you 24/7, even while you’re working on your next book.
And the best part? You don’t have to do it alone. By learning the ins and outs of social media marketing and creating content that aligns with your goals, you can create a sustainable author brand that sells books and builds a loyal, engaged community of readers.
Follow and Connect with Danielle Wright
About
“Danielle is a multi-genre romance author, seamlessly weaving stories that bridge the past and present. From the sweeping depth of historical romance to the raw emotion of contemporary love stories, her work explores themes of healing, resilience, and human connection. She’s also a poet, crafting verses that cut straight to the heart. Whether through prose or poetry, her writing is known for its rich storytelling, deep character exploration, and emotional depth that lingers long after the last page.
“But storytelling isn’t just her passion—it’s her business. With a decade of experience in author branding and digital marketing, Danielle helps indie authors master the art of selling books without feeling salesy. Through her coaching, content creation, and signature program, The Visibility Advantage, she teaches authors how to build powerful, personality-driven brands that attract loyal readers and drive book sales. Her no-fluff, psychology-backed marketing strategies make social media feel effortless, turning overwhelmed writers into confident, strategic marketers.
Whether she’s crafting compelling narratives or helping authors take their brands from barely noticed to bestseller, Danielle’s mission is clear: to make marketing work for authors—without the burnout.
Social Media
Connect with her on Tiktok or Instagram at @roseavenueliterary or visit her website www.roseavenueliterary.com.”
Leave a comment